Sunday, September 18, 2016

Concept of Othering

Wing Young Huie's photo, "Schalmer Flying Horse," taken in 2001 features a woman sitting alone on a public bus or subway.  The women is the focus of the image, which creates emphasis and contrast between her and the blurred bodies that stand in the foreground. Contrast is also created from the picture being black and white, the woman's shirt is a pure white against the dark black seats.  The artist captured the feeling of loneliness, which is communicated through her facial expression.  The concept of "othering" is present in this photograph since the woman in focus is in the background of the image, which creates a sense that she is separated or alienated from the rest of the crowd.  Huie furthers this concept by having the focus of the image, dressed in white, surrounded by two blurred figures, dressed in darker clothing, again creating the sense of separation. 

Simular to Huie's photograph, "Schalmer Flying Horse," Margaret Atwood's novel, The Handmaid's Tale, also captures the concept of "othering."  Atwood creates this concept through gender stereotypes, by the creation of the different classes. Women were assigned as Wives, Handmaids, Marthas, Econowives, or "unwomen."  Women that could bear children became Handmaids, while those who could not became Marthas.  Those who revolted against the new society became "unwomen" and forced to do manual labor.  The use of the neologism, "unwomen," captures the concept of "othering" because the "unwomen" were separated from the rest of Gilead's society.  The different classes were divided by colors and rules that banned certain behavior among the classes creating a division amongst the population and furthers the concept of "othering" throughout Atwood's novel. 


3 comments:

  1. I agree with what you say about othering! I like how you were able to explain how women were organized in the book to support your argument. The point about how women were divided visually is good to include about people being exclusively bound to a group of services women performed. The concept of othering is supported well here.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I like your description of the photo and how you described Huie's way of making her look like any outsider or other. I totally agree with you about the way she is the only clear thing but is in the background instead of the foreground. This makes her the focus of the picture but paints her as obviously not important in societies eyes because of her position. An important person would have been in the foreground. Good job with pointing out this othering.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Strong examination and comparison of othering; I would have liked to have seen more of a smaller-level annotation of the photograph. Think about the Big 5 to make sure you've touched on basis elements before moving into your analysis.

    ReplyDelete